I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Do whatever you want here. Anything goes. (EDIT: July 2020, board is back up and working!)

Moderators: klefmop, neck_cannon, Andrew, thebigmin, steven

User avatar
neck_cannon
Posts: 1265
Joined: Tue May 04, 2010 3:08 pm

Re: I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Post by neck_cannon »

Will all of you shut the fuck up?

It's a good list dude. SO glad that ILM is on there and not Saetia.

User avatar
TehBurgerKing
Posts: 256
Joined: Mon Jun 21, 2010 7:41 pm
Location: Wilkesboro, NC

Re: I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Post by TehBurgerKing »

Gnarlin Gnartree wrote:Not bad list, I just dont see how anyone doesnt include Funeral Diner in their top ten list, or pg.99 (if you consider them a screamo band, I guess some dont).
Pg. 99 aren't that good imho. And when do you think you'll get the article on stuffyouwillhate, bigmin?

User avatar
thebigmin
Posts: 1570
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:10 pm
Location: Los Angeles, Ca
Contact:

Re: I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Post by thebigmin »

Gnarlin Gnartree wrote:Not bad list, I just dont see how anyone doesnt include Funeral Diner in their top ten list, or pg.99 (if you consider them a screamo band, I guess some dont).
i put portraits of past instead of funeral diner because they are the godfathers. Pg.99 isn't a pure screamo band in my definition.

Gnarlin Gnartree
Posts: 504
Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2010 10:39 pm

Re: I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Post by Gnarlin Gnartree »

TehBurgerKing wrote:
Gnarlin Gnartree wrote:Not bad list, I just dont see how anyone doesnt include Funeral Diner in their top ten list, or pg.99 (if you consider them a screamo band, I guess some dont).
Pg. 99 aren't that good imho. And when do you think you'll get the article on stuffyouwillhate, bigmin?
I will never understand the people who arent on pg.99's dick like I am.

User avatar
thebigmin
Posts: 1570
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:10 pm
Location: Los Angeles, Ca
Contact:

Re: I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Post by thebigmin »

neck_cannon wrote: SO glad that ILM is on there and not Saetia.
yup

Gnarlin Gnartree
Posts: 504
Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2010 10:39 pm

Re: I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Post by Gnarlin Gnartree »

thebigmin wrote:
Gnarlin Gnartree wrote:Not bad list, I just dont see how anyone doesnt include Funeral Diner in their top ten list, or pg.99 (if you consider them a screamo band, I guess some dont).
i put portraits of past instead of funeral diner because they are the godfathers. Pg.99 isn't a pure screamo band in my definition.
Fair enough. I guess it depends on the importance you give to longevity or who did it first.

User avatar
thebigmin
Posts: 1570
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:10 pm
Location: Los Angeles, Ca
Contact:

Re: I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Post by thebigmin »

TehBurgerKing wrote: And when do you think you'll get the article on stuffyouwillhate, bigmin?
working on the write up right now, hopefully sometime this week i'm trying to make it extensive.

User avatar
thebigmin
Posts: 1570
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:10 pm
Location: Los Angeles, Ca
Contact:

Re: I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Post by thebigmin »

Gnarlin Gnartree wrote:
thebigmin wrote:
Gnarlin Gnartree wrote:Not bad list, I just dont see how anyone doesnt include Funeral Diner in their top ten list, or pg.99 (if you consider them a screamo band, I guess some dont).
i put portraits of past instead of funeral diner because they are the godfathers. Pg.99 isn't a pure screamo band in my definition.
Fair enough. I guess it depends on the importance you give to longevity or who did it first.
portraits of past was the first true screamo band ever PERIOD. 1995. Funeral Diner are obviously big time legends and matt badja is my hero but i am putting portraits of past in, there will be mentions to FD and other half moon bay bands though.

User avatar
clayt0n
Posts: 133
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2010 10:05 pm
Location: Urbana, ILL

Re: I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Post by clayt0n »

not surprising to see bigmin on a website listing things i hate :roll:

User avatar
brianutatx
Posts: 1414
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 7:32 pm
Location: Austin TX

Re: I'm doing a top 10 screamo bands of all time list..

Post by brianutatx »

thebigmin wrote:
brianutatx wrote:
thebigmin wrote:yo i wasnt asking for anyone eleses list...this is my list for my blog was just sharing...These are the bands that define the genre for me, i dont give a shit about your newjack band lists
All us "newjacks" realized obvious flaws in your list just wanted to give you a helping hand. True scene unity helping each other out in the spirit of screamo DIY etc. etc.

StuffUwillhate isn't that funny or relevant most of the time. The joke is played out at this point
dude you're list of bands are pretty much the most elementary to the genre and equal to what some bridge nine messageboard idiot would list...and i've actually seen half of the bands in your list live so give me a break. I'm not saying they aren't good but definitely not a top 10.
I can see how you would put my list as elementary, I didn't put my favorite top 10, but more a top 10 list for most influential to the genre. A good majority of the bands you put on your list I despise and I think are complete shit for screamo bands and music in general. I don't give a shit who you have or haven't seen live, I'm not trying to get in a dick measuring contest with you. My comment was in jest anyway, you don't get it.
Image

Post Reply